What’s the difference between yoga and pilates?

Frequently, people ask me what the difference is between yoga and pilates and if they should practice one versus the other. While there are differences, there are many elements of pilates and yoga that complement each other.

Yoga which means “union,” is a highly sophisticated system of whole-body integration. It has a physical component, the asana (postures or poses) that promote toning and strengthening muscles, flexibility and range of motion, balance and relaxation. It generates motion without causing strain or imbalance in the body. It also asks for a full union of body, mind and spirit, so you can’t be distracted while doing yoga–you need to be fully present. Yoga is a spiritual practice, providing tools to help quiet the mind, become more grounded, and live in harmony and tranquility.

Pilates, on the other hand, is an exercise form developed by Joseph H. Pilates during World War I. The Pilates method emphasizes building strength and improving posture, balance, coordination and stamina. The exercises can be done on the floor (mat-based Pilates) and on specialized equipment. Designed to strengthen, stretch, and stabilize muscles without building bulk, Pilates can benefit anyone. In Pilates, emphasis is placed on ensuring that the movement is done fluidly, but, accurately: The quality of the movement is more important than the number of repetitions completed.

So, what are the similarities between the two methods?

• Both methods facilitate deep concentration and integration of the whole body. Often described as the mind-body connection, this leads one to be fully present and in the moment
• Both improve alignment and posture and create a sense of balance in the body.
• Both forms are excellent for injury prevention. Both promote healing and help facilitate recovery from injury.
• Both are interested in creating a sense of energetic flow through the body, facilitating grace, poise and coordination.
• Both forms have been “tried and tested.” They aren’t just some new fitness fad.

What are some of the main differences?

• Yoga adds a spiritual element to the mix. The Indian sage Patanjali wrote the yoga sutras thousands of years ago, describing the spiritual and philosophical path of yoga.
• Yoga takes a holistic approach to the body, while Pilates focuses on a specific area called “The Powerhouse.”
• Pilates improves flexibility by fluidly moving the limbs in their full range of motion against a stable base of support, while yoga improves flexibility by lengthening muscles during dynamic poses (asanas).
• Yoga offers tools to aid in relaxation, relieving stress, and meditation.
• Breathing is very important in both forms, but the technique is different.

Why is the combination so beneficial?

• The concentration required in a Pilates workout really helps build the focus that is required for doing the yoga asanas (poses), pranayama (breathing techniques), and meditation.
• The focus on precision and movement technique, emphasized in Pilates, assists the yoga student to work more correctly.
• The asana in yoga give the Pilates student a broader scope of practice to apply stability and good technique.
• The stronger core body developed in Pilates, gives the student confidence to go more deeply into their yoga practice, more safely.

Practicing both Pilates and Yoga, gives a student more tools for developing a whole body that is vital, aware and adaptable.

How to work with prenatal clients

• This question was sent and responded to through email, but we thought others might be interested!

Hello ladies!

I am beginning to teach both mat and reformer to a woman 6 weeks pregnant. With her last child she did not do any physical exercise because she was afraid of miscarrying. However, she would like to try Pilates once a week throughout this pregnancy. Can you give me some tips to use when working with her? Also, she hasn’t done Pilates for the last month and is worried that since she has been “out of practice”, starting up again will be like starting a new exercise program–which is not recommended in prenatal books. I assured her that this would not be a problem, but she would like the official word from the experts at PNWP.

Thanks so much!

Answer from Jean Leavenworth:

Hi there-
I am curious why she stopped exercising completely during her first pregnancy. Was she at risk for miscarrying? That is something to find out as it could still be an issue, and I would highly recommend that she is released by her physician to work with you during this pregnancy and that she is given permission to work with you through each trimester; the first trimester has the highest risk of miscarriage, so it is important that she has been cleared for exercise.

General contraindications during pregancy:

1.) no inverted exercises e.g. rollovers, short spine, etc

2.) no extreme stretching due to lax ligaments, especially side splits!

3.) Prone exercises may be uncomfortable due to breast tenderness and after the first trimester will need to be replaced by a quadruped position.
after 20 weeks, work in an inclined plane instead of supine (use arc barrel, spine supporter or similar device to keep upper body elevated)
be cautious about over-exertion or letting the body get over heated. Strengthening the core muscles will be very helpful to prevent excess lordosis during the pregnancy and it may help during the delivery process too.

4.) Pelvic floor exercises are great, but emphasis should also be placed on learning how to relax and release the pelvic floor too.

5.) side lying leg work is great to strengthen the abductors–use a pillow under belly as pregnancy progresses.

6.) arm work and upper body strength is important to prepare the new mom for carrying the baby around and all the other heavy baby stuff!

7.) Check for any changes in the diastus recti. If it separates during pregnancy, then extra care will need to be taken post-partum to avoid increasing separation of the rectus muscle. Flexion should be avoided or any other exercise that causes the diastus to increase. Strengthening the TA while keeping the spine neutral is optimal for healing the herniation.

Let me know if that makes sense!
Best wishes-
Jean

Osteoporosis & Pilates

This question was sent and responded to through email, but we thought others might be interested!

Hi Pacific Northwest,
This is Christi Tuck from the YMCA in Colorado Springs. I thought I would run this question by your studio since over the years we have had your instructors come out to the Springs to do our CEC’s. Anyways, I have a client that was recently diagnosed with osteoporosis of the spine and osteopenia of the hip. I have done quite a bit of research regarding safe exercises for her, however I am still not sure about backward flexion, e.g. backrowing roll-down on the reformer … I know to avoid all forward flexion and lateral flexion. Her doctor said minimal spinal rotation with no resistance would be okay. Any thoughts on the backward flexion??
Thanks for any information you can provide. Have a great holiday weekend.

Sincerely,

Christi Tuck

Answer from Leslie Braverman:

Hi Christi:

This is a great question!

The conservative approach is to omit all flexion and rotation from a client’s workout. Unfortunately, most normal people have to conduct some flexion and rotation in their daily lives, so, in my opinion, it is a good idea that they know how to do these movements appropriately and without alot of loaded compression. Practically speaking, an individual will have to do these movements but should be educated to know what is appropriate for the overall health of their bones.

The thing I try to do is to make sure that the flexion and rotation is never in a loaded position and is done minimally during a workout (i.e. with lots of exercises that include extension and neutral spine spaced between.) Loaded flexion includes ANY inverted work. I would make certain never to do any roll over, short spine type of exercises. Especially because the thoracic spine can fracture easily, you want to make very sure that you omit these kinds of exercises—easily done. This is, of course, something to keep in mind when working in a group setting, also, when you don’t know all the students or their history very well.

In addition, you may need to be cautious with other types of loaded rotation or flexion that uses alot of spring tension or sends a great amount of loaded compression through the spine (I would be careful with things like stomach massage and elephant in a round back position). Also, exercises that combine flexion and rotation in one should, generally, be omitted (i.e. saw, stomach massage with twist etc.)

Do your best to keep your client working in neutral positions as much as possible. As an important aside, loading the bones in other ways would be great and makes Pilates a safe and effective tool for bone building! (i.e. footwork, jumping on the STOTT PILATES® jumpboard, armwork with the spine in a neutral position) all of these types of exercises are going to help your client to build bone without stressing one particular area of the spine too much. Good for you…. being a smart and inquisitive instructor!

I also hope that Melanie and Jean will put in their two (or three) cents!

I hope you are well…all my best to everyone in Colorado Springs.

Leslie

Reply from Christi:

Hi Leslie,
Thank you so much for your quick reply. Your information was invaluable and it also helped confirm the changes I have made to her workout. We had a private session on Friday with omitting the exercises you have mentioned with a main focus on staying neutral. She attended my reformer class yesterday so I was able to ask her how her body responded with the changes we made and I am pleased to say she felt great. Fortunately, she has been doing pilates for a while so her mind/body focus is wonderful. I am happy to hear that you think the jumpboard is a good option because she enjoys it. Thanks again for all your information.

Sincerely,

Christi Tuck